SPOILER ALERT! This post will ruin the movie if you haven’t seen it.
–
Hollywood always seems do this. They tell an amazing story, filled with plot twists and amazing acting, but in the end leave society with the wrong message, all for the sake of a few bucks. Hollywood isn’t the only one guilty of this, we see it all the time. Popular music (especially country) does it and marketing agencies for big companies exploit customers by re-enforcing our bad habits every day.
It can all be summed up in one word…
Glamorization.
When country artists sing about alcohol, they glamorize drinking and perpetuate the alcohol problem we have in the United States. All for a few bucks.
When Taco Bell advertises “4th meal”, they perpetuate our habit of eating late and contribute to the overall decline in the health of Americans. All for a few bucks.
When the TV industry continually puts out family sitcoms with weak, pea-brained husbands (Modern Family, Everybody Loves Raymond, Family Guy, King of Queens, etc…), it’s perpetuating the idea that men are weak and completely inept to the point of humor. All for a few bucks.
This is where Black Swan fails.
Let me first digress about some positives. This movie was extremely well done. I thought the acting was very moving and the story was delivered as well as it could have been. The relationship between the main character and her Mother was absolutely fascinating and one that I know many people can unfortunately relate to.
The end is what killed me.
Whether you realized it or not, the message sent to the public was “a perfect artist is one who’s inner turmoil is the greatest”. The movie ends with Natalie Portman (Nina) killing herself and declaring to the director and dance company that in that moment she was “perfect”, and that belief is not questioned. Mila Kunis’ character Lily is truly the only well-adjusted character in the whole movie. She’s positive, non-self destructive and an extremely talented dancer, yet we view her through the eyes of Nina, who sees her as vindictive, amoral and dishonest. Although when we think about it we realize that all the negative character traits of Lily are in Nina’s head, we can’t help but feel that she is not the kind of person we’d want to associate with, when it reality, she was the only person that reached out to Nina and at least tried to give her what she needed. This is not an accident!!! The writers and director of this movie knew exactly what they were doing and we feel exactly how they intended for us to feel! It’s no different from the marketing meeting at Taco Bell when they ask “how can we suck more money out of all the fat-ass Americans that buy our product? Let’s convince them that the stupid shit they already do is OK!”
It’s wrong. Teaching our society that as artist you need to struggle, do drugs, have issues, or whatever other fucked up condition Hollywood and the music industry will present HURTS America and we hardly seem to care. NO ONE talks about how Black Swan contributes to the thousands of artists that will hurt themselves, become addicted to drugs, or commit suicide, but what happens when Janet Jackson shows her breast at the Superbowl Halftime show?
Please talk about this movie and spread a positive message. Don’t let people think that the way to become a great artist is to torture yourself.
